Alice Neel: Hot Off the Griddle review – a ‘momentous’ exhibition at the Barbican

The painter Alice Neel was neglected in her lifetime, but is today “celebrated for her unflinching yet compassionate gaze”, said Chloë Ashby in The Times. Born into a conservative family in Pennsylvania, Neel (1900-1984) rejected her roots, married a Cuban émigré and became a committed communist, living a bohemian existence in New York’s Spanish Harlem. 

She specialised in “candid and unconventional” portraits of “lovers and neighbours, heavily pregnant women, queer couples, artists and writers, black intellectuals” – looking beyond the conventions of portraiture to focus on figures marginalised on account of their sexuality, race or class. “Life itself, unvarnished and fresh – hot off the griddle, she  called it.” Neel was painting while abstraction was in its heyday, and she was ignored for much of her career. 

In recent decades, however, her eccentric figurative work has won her cult status – and as this thrilling survey at the Barbican demonstrates, the attention is well-deserved. Bringing together 70 paintings from every stage of Neel’s long career, the show is a testament to her genius for capturing not just “outward appearances but inner lives”. It is a “momentous” exhibition. 

Alice Neel’s 1980 self-portrait

The Estate of Alice Neel

Neel was not out to flatter, said Alastair Sooke in The Daily Telegraph. The first thing we see is a striking self-portrait she painted at the age of 80, in which she “presents herself as a grandmotherly, bespectacled lady with white hair, sitting naked, while holding a brush”. She captures her “drooping breasts and wobbly tummy”, her hand “seemingly gangrenous”. 

It’s a work typical of her matter-of-fact approach. Yet while there is much that is admirable about Neel’s work, it’s hard to get past its fundamental “weaknesses”. She was “terrible” at painting hands, and had an annoying tendency to make her subjects’ heads “disproportionately large”. 

Some of these portraits are plain bad: she really “drops the ball” in a “marionette-like” portrait of Andy Warhol’s assistant Gerard Malanga, while a “horrid” likeness of the poet Frank O’Hara is “an abortive piece of painting”. 

Neel’s 1954 work entitled Rita and Hubert

The Estate of Alice Neel

Neel’s style is certainly “ungainly”, said Laura Cumming in The Observer. Yet to criticise her work for lacking “correctness of proportion” or photorealistic accuracy is to miss the point. Her paintings are near to caricature, but much odder: they speak to the “weird” coexistence of our minds and our bodies. 

A “notorious” 1933 painting of the “wildly eccentric writer” Joe Gould has him surrounded by “tiers of male genitals”; her lover John Rothschild is “seen peeing in the sink” as he examines a “wriggling critter” in the palm of his hand. Elsewhere, Warhol himself is memorably depicted half-naked shortly after a 1968 attempt on his life, in a surgical truss. Overall, this is a “terrific” show that captures Neel’s tremendous “force of personality”.

Barbican Art Gallery, London EC1 (020-7870 2500, barbican.org.uk). Until 21 May; barbican.org.uk

Article source: https://www.theweek.co.uk/arts-life/culture/art/959984/alice-neel-hot-off-the-griddle-exhibition-review